www.vuletic.com/hume
 
Defender's Guide to Science and Creationism
Assertion: Radiometric dating only seems to indicate an old Earth because Noah's Flood changed the radioisotope concentrations in the young Earth.

Mark I. Vuletic
e-mail

Last updated 21 March 2008

Analysis

(i) If a worldwide cataclysmic flood had changed the radioisotope concentrations in terrestrial rock, one would expect radiometric dating to yield a completely haphazard distribution of ages as one tested rock strata progressively deeper in the Earth. However, lower strata consistently date older than higher strata (except where overthrust has occurred).

(ii) Radiometric dating of moonrocks and meteorites consistently yields dates of around 4.5 billion years, which is approximately the age of the earth according to standard geology. Since a worldwide flood could not have affected the radioisotope concentrations of moonrocks and meteorites (unless it somehow managed to engulf the entire solar system), these dates give us independent evidence that the radioisotope concentrations of terrestrial rocks were not distorted by a flood either. It would be too great a coincidence for the dates to just happen to match.

(iii) There is no plausible evidence for a worldwide Flood.

All Disqus comments will be moderated. Please use common sense. If you are not sure what counts as common sense, do a search for "comment etiquette."

Comments powered by Disqus